top of page

Generation Z's Trust Shift: How Influencers Became New Age Recommendations in Influencer Marketing

Generation Z's Trust Shift on Influencer Marketing
Generation Z's Trust Shift on Influencer Marketing

Introduction to Influencer Marketing

Influencer marketing, as defined in scholarly articles, is a contemporary digital strategy where brands collaborate with individuals possessing a dedicated online following, leveraging their credibility to promote products/services. This approach capitalizes on influencers' ability to authentically connect with audiences, enhancing brand visibility and engagement within the digital realm.

In the realm of marketing's evolution, influencer marketing has emerged as a potent strategy. Contrary to modern perceptions, its origins date back to the 18th century. Wedgwood, a potter, pioneered modern marketing by aligning his pottery with Queen Charlotte. This article pays homage to these pioneers who paved the way for new professions and income streams. The growth of influencer marketing, culminating in the rise of platforms like Qoruz, underscores their impact.

The strategy of using fictional characters in influencer marketing is notable. For instance, Coca-Cola's collaboration with Santa Claus during the Great Depression boosted sales. Similarly, Homepride's character "Fred the Flour Grader" and Polaroid's partnership with the Muppets demonstrate the power of fiction in marketing.

Transitioning to non-fictional influencers, celebrities entered the fray, capitalizing on their substantial fan bases. Despite controversies, Roscoe Arbuckle became the first celebrity product endorser for Murad cigarettes. Marilyn Monroe's association with Coco Chanel's little black dress challenged conventions, influencing fashion perceptions. Nike's partnership with Michael Jordan for Air Jordan 6 '84 catapulted both the brand and the athlete to iconic status.

In the modern context, influencer marketing's effectiveness has grown substantially. Instagram provided a global platform for ordinary individuals to become influencers, while brands sought famous influencers for product promotion. This expansion has extended to TikTok and Twitter, driving up infrastructure costs. Astonishing statistics reflect the strategy's potency: 93% of marketers find influencer marketing effective, and India's influencer market is projected to reach 22 billion Indian rupees by 2025, from the current 9 billion.

In essence, influencer marketing's history demonstrates its enduring power, uniting fictional, non-fictional, and celebrity influencers to reshape marketing landscapes.

Types of Influencers

- There are 4 types - Mega, macro, micro, and nano influencers

In the realm of influencer marketing, distinct categories exist based on follower counts and engagement levels.

Mega-influencers, with follower counts exceeding one million, offer broad reach but at a high cost. Though famous, they lack targeted influence due to their diverse audience.

Macro-influencers sit below mega-influencers with follower counts between 100,000 and one million. They gained fame through the internet and cater to specific demographics, making them suitable for broad-reaching yet focused campaigns.

Micro-influencers, with 1,000 to 100,000 followers, emphasize niche expertise and strong audience relationships. They yield higher engagement and prove effective for products resonating with their speciality.

Nano-influencers, a newer category, have under 1,000 followers. Operating within local communities, they excel at authentic engagement. Brands working with nano-influencers convey an organic feel due to genuine connections.

While mega-influencers offer broad exposure, micro and nano-influencers hold more authenticity and engagement within specific niches. Selecting the right category depends on a brand's product, target audience, and marketing goals. Considering the balance between reach and authenticity is pivotal for a successful influencer campaign.

The Role of Influencers in the Digital Age

The Role of Influencers in the Digital Age
The Role of Influencers in the Digital Age

Trust and credibility are fundamental pillars for successful influencer marketing campaigns, especially in the era of constant advertising bombardment. In the digital landscape, influencers are seen as reliable sources by their followers, impacting their decisions. Establishing authenticity and integrity in influencer partnerships is vital, as consumers heavily rely on online reviews for informed choices. A notable 93% of millennials consider online reviews essential. Hence, maintaining trust and credibility is imperative for influencer marketing's effectiveness. Machine learning aids in identifying authenticity, analyzing engagement rates, and detecting potential red flags, safeguarding campaign integrity. Real-time monitoring tracks key metrics, allowing timely intervention in case of ethical breaches.

Forming enduring relationships between influencers and brands is another key strategy. Long-term partnerships foster genuine connections, indicating shared values. Such relationships showcase consistency, enhancing influencers' trustworthiness. In the ever-evolving influencer landscape, agencies hold the responsibility to champion ethical practices and transparency. By leveraging technology and nurturing enduring bonds, agencies can construct a foundation of trust that benefits both brands and consumers. In the end, prioritizing trust bolsters influencer marketing's impact and long-term brand-consumer relationships.

Benefits of Influencer Marketing

Benefits of Influencer Marketing
Benefits of Influencer Marketing

1. High ROI of Influencer Marketing:

- A quarter of current influencer marketing users report it provides the second-highest return on investment among various marketing trends. This indicates that investments in influencer marketing yield valuable results and are not wasted.

2. Cost Efficiency through Influencers:

- Given the substantial ROI, influencer marketing can be a cost-effective approach. Partnering with smaller micro-influencers, especially those with fewer than 100k followers, can optimize campaign budgets while still generating significant ROI. Nearly 44% of marketers working with both large and small influencers find the cost advantage in collaborating with smaller influencers.

3. Influencer Trust Among Gen Z:

- For Generation Z, influencer recommendations carry more weight than those from friends and family. This shift signifies that influencers' impact has grown, surpassing the traditional sources of trust when making purchasing decisions. The advice of influencers is now as influential as that of friends and family, highlighting their sway.

4. Social Proof and Brand Awareness:

- Influencer marketing leads in generating authentic content, building social proof, and enhancing brand awareness. The credibility of influencer endorsements adds authenticity to your brand, fostering trust. The comparison is drawn between a brand self-promoting and an influencer sharing their genuine admiration, with the latter being more persuasive.

5. Influencer Impact on Purchases:

- A third of Generation Z has made purchases based on influencer recommendations within the last three months. This demonstrates influencers' capacity to directly drive purchases, particularly among younger consumers who are significantly influenced by this approach.

6. Building Long-Term Relationships:

- Partnering with smaller influencers offers the advantage of nurturing enduring relationships. These ongoing collaborations enhance credibility among an influencer's audience, showing consistent endorsement of your products and services, thereby strengthening trust.

7. Authentic Humanized Content:

- Influencer marketing not only reaches the intended audience but does so authentically and genuinely. Influencers convey messages as recommendations from real individuals who have cultivated devoted communities founded on trust. This resonates well with the shift towards more relatable and humanized content that appeals to modern consumers.

Case Studies and Success Stories

1. Nike Air Vapormax Campaign:

Nike, a global leader in athletic wear, engaged in influencer marketing to promote their Air Vapormax series. Collaborating with the YouTube channel "What's Inside?", known for dissecting objects, the brand leveraged a father-son duo's unique approach to showcase the new product. In a series of seven videos, the influencers integrated Nike's messaging into their content, engaging their 6 million subscribers. This collaboration included vlogs, Q&As, and a video cutting up a Nike Air Vapormax, garnering 3.6 million views and building anticipation for the product.

2. Subaru's "Meet an Owner" Campaign:

Subaru achieved a 10% sales increase with an impactful influencer campaign. They partnered with 20 influencers across diverse niches, from fitness to art. The influencers produced content highlighting Subaru cars and injecting their authentic voices. Notably, influencer Zach King created a video showcasing a Subaru car, gaining over 8 million views. The "Meet an Owner" campaign gained a 9% engagement rate, generating numerous comments and millions of likes for 58 sponsored posts. It led to improved brand awareness, contributing to Subaru's growth.

3. Youfoodz's Winter Menu Launch:

Australian fresh meal provider Youfoodz tapped into Instagram influencers specializing in health, fitness, and food to promote their winter menu launch. Partnering with 81 influencers, they generated 167 content pieces and 162 Instagram stories. These efforts garnered almost 70,000 engagements and 500,000 impressions, reaching 1.5 million people on Facebook and Instagram. The use of Instagram Stories facilitated authentic content, effectively engaging the target audience.

4. Pottery Barn's Collaboration with Decor8:

Pottery Barn collaborated with interior design influencer Holly Becker of Decor8 to promote their Ken Fulk collection. The influencer creatively showcased the collection's pieces, offering unique ideas for incorporating them into homes. The campaign generated substantial engagement, including 500 reader comments and a social reach of around 4 million, effectively promoting the collection.

5. Gerber's Lil' Beanies Launch:

Gerber's Lil' Beanies launch aimed to enhance brand awareness and drive sales. Partnering with 324 influencers, including parents of toddlers, they crafted original content showcasing their product as a nutritious snack. The campaign produced 9,400 pieces of content, generating 9.2 million potential impressions and inspiring around 260,000 engagements. The campaign contributed to a national sales increase of nearly 5% for Gerber's Lil' Beanies products.

6. Maybelline's Falsies Push-Up Drama Campaign:

Maybelline collaborated with beauty influencers to raise awareness and sales for their Falsies Push Up Drama mascara, available at Walmart. These influencers created content focused on beauty tips, tricks, and beauty hauls, driving in-store traffic and highlighting the product's features. The campaign resulted in substantial views, impressions, and increased media value.

7. Society6's Millennial Target Campaign:

Society6 partnered with millennial women influencers, aiming to increase brand awareness and target a broad demographic. These influencers created videos showcasing Society6 products that personalized college dorm rooms. The campaign garnered over a million video views and an engagement rate of 5.68%.

8. GOODFOODS' Brand Awareness and Sales Boost:

GOODFOODS collaborated with influencers across food, parenting, lifestyle, and home niches to raise brand awareness and drive sales for their guacamole and dips. The influencers crafted original recipes and stories incorporating GOODFOODS products. The campaign generated 2,000 content pieces, achieving 34 million potential impressions, 71,000 engagements, and a conversion rate of 34.2%. The content was further republished through Nativo, yielding an even higher conversion rate of 44.5%.

Challenges and Risks in Influencer Marketing

1. Fake Influencers Concern: Counterfeit influencers pose a significant issue for brands in the influencer marketing landscape. The selection of influencers is paramount, as campaign success hinges on this choice. The prevalence of fraudulent influencers on social media platforms not only impacts brands negatively but also deceives users. Instances of influencers with bogus followers undermine campaigns. This erosion of trust can lead to users doubting the brand's authenticity, leading to adverse effects on the organization's reputation. To prevent mishaps, a rigorous evaluation of influencers before selection is crucial.

2. Effective Influencer Management: Managing influencers during campaign implementation is a distinct challenge that encompasses various tasks. This includes delivering campaign briefs, assessing outcomes, planning content, and more. Often, marketers encounter difficulties in this realm, resulting in disagreements with influencers and misunderstandings regarding campaign objectives. Establishing a structured management process is essential, incorporating clear communication and adhering to brand guidelines to ensure smooth campaign execution.

3. Target Audience Precision: A key challenge is accurately pinpointing the target audience for influencer campaigns. Merely reaching a broad audience is insufficient. Strategic selection requires meticulous consideration of demographics, interests, and related factors. Careful research is necessary to identify the audience genuinely interested in the product or service. Taking into account location and audience preferences aids in shaping a relevant and impactful influencer marketing campaign.

4. Influence Beyond Follower Count: The misconception that higher follower counts equate to greater influence is debunked. The relationship between influencers and audiences is evolving, with user discernment impacting engagement. Relying solely on follower quantity for campaign efficacy is no longer viable. In many instances, influencers with substantial followings fail to garner meaningful engagement. Brands must focus on connecting genuinely with users, as influencer marketing effectiveness extends beyond follower metrics.

5. Measuring Performance and ROI: Determining the success of influencer marketing campaigns remains a challenge due to the absence of standardized evaluation methods. While engagement rates and post-implementation sales offer insights, calculating precise return on investment (ROI) is intricate. Influencing factors extend beyond direct correlation, making comprehensive ROI assessment elusive. Comparing post-campaign sales data yields approximate results due to multifaceted influencing variables.

6. Relevance in Influencer Selection: The struggle to identify influencers aligned with brand values and audience persists. Despite the availability of influencer databases, mismatched influencer choices hinder campaigns. This issue can be mitigated through advanced influencer tracking tools such as Unbox Social, enabling effective influencer assessment based on industry tiers and performance metrics.

7. Engagement Challenges in Sponsored Content: Rising influencers may struggle to deliver desired engagement in sponsored posts. Content alignment with brand messaging is crucial. User scepticism toward sponsored content further complicates engagement rates. Successful sponsored posts require meticulous planning to effectively convey brand messages and foster genuine audience interaction.

8. Long-Term Collaboration Complexities: Establishing enduring relationships with social media influencers is intricate due to the competitive landscape. The multitude of influencers and brands complicates long-term collaborations. Unclear regulations lead to influencers collaborating with competing brands. To overcome this, brand managers must establish transparent expectations to foster sustainable partnerships.


Influencer marketing, a dynamic strategy in today's digital landscape, wields the power to amplify brand reach and engagement. While harnessing its potential, businesses navigate challenges such as fake influencers, precise targeting, and measuring ROI. By fostering genuine relationships, utilizing advanced tools, and aligning content with authenticity, influencer marketing remains a valuable avenue for brand growth.


Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page